I have three of these holsters available and they fit the S&W Shield I have. I have not tested them on the Shield 2, but they are not designed for a Shield with a light mounted below the barrel.
This holster is not reversible, so it can be worn IWB for a righthander or OWB for a lefthander.
If you can meet in New Albany, I am fine with allowing you to test the fit before purchasing.
Pickup is in New Albany OR shipping is available upon request. I will need a full address to provide an accurate shipping quote.